The Blue Jays brought in 29-year old righty swinging catcher John Buck to start behind the plate in 2010. He played in 59 games for the Royals last season and he was 46 for 186 (.247 avg, .783 OPS) with 16 runs scored, 8 homers and 36 RBIs. Buck will provide some random power but he is a .235 career hitter in the majors and he has whiffed 500 times in 1,913 career at bats so don’t expect miracles out of him with the bat. The Blue Jays better also hope the Buck gets better on defense with them. He made 8 errors and he had 2 passed balls in on 46 games behind the plate for the Royals last season. Buck only threw out 16% of the runners trying to steal on him last season and Royals’ pitchers had a 5.18 ERA with him behind the plate. It’s hard to find anything that makes me think that Buck will play well for the Blue Jays in 2010.
36-year old righty swinging Raul Chavez will serve as Buck’s back-up behind the plate next season. He played in 51 games for the Blue Jays last season and he was 41 for 159 (.258 avg, .631 OPS) with 10 runs scored, 2 homers and 15 RBIs. He doesn’t have Buck’s power and his career .231 batting average (.570 OPS) don’t inspire much confidence in him as a hitter. But, Chavez is a better defensive catcher than Buck. He made 2 errors in 51 games and he had 5 passed balls behind the plate for the Jays last season. The passed balls are a major concern for them going forward but Chavez should improve in that area. Chavez threw out 36% of the runners trying to steal on him last season and Blue Jays’ pitchers had a 4.85 ERA with him behind the plate. Look for Chavez to get more playing time in 2010 than he got in 2009.
PROJECTED GRADE FOR THE CATCHERS IN 2010: D