The Toronto Blue Jays have six free agents going into this winter and they are all pretty decent players. If I were the G.M. these are the decisions I would make with these guys:
Lyle Overbay: 33-year old lefty swinging 1B Lyle Overbay has been paid pretty well by the Blue Jays despite putting up so-so numbers. He played in 154 games for the Blue Jays last season and he was 130 of 534 (.243 avg, .762 OPS) with 75 runs scored, 20 homers and 67 RBIs. VERDICT: The free agent market is flooded with 1B better than Overbay. I would let him test the market and then offer him a take it or leave it 1-year deal worth $3 million bucks.
John Buck: 30-year old righty swinging catcher John Buck came through with a career year for the Jays on a 1-year deal. Buck played in 118 games for the Blue Jays last season and he was 115 of 409 (.281 avg, .802 OPS) with 53 runs scored, 20 homers and 66 RBIs. He is one of the better free agent catchers so he won’t be cheap. VERDICT: Unless Buck is willing to sign a 1-year deal again I would let him walk and start rookie J.P. Arencibia at catcher in 2011.
Jose Molina: 35-year old righty swinging catcher Jose Molina played in 57 games for the Jays last season and he was 41 of 167 (.246 avg, .681 OPS) with 13 runs scored, 6 homers and 12 RBIs. Molina is a great defensive catcher who works well with the pitching staff. Brandon Morrow really excelled when pitching to him. The Blue Jays hold a $1.2 million dollar club option on him. VERDICT: If the Blue Jays were smart they would pick up Molina’s option for 2011.
Scott Downs: 34-year old lefty reliever Scott Downs has turned into one of the best lefty relievers in all of baseball after coming to Toronto. He pitched in 67 games (0 starts) for the Blue Jays last season and he was 5-5 with a 2.64 ERA and a 1.00 WHIP. VERDICT: I would let both Lyle Overbay and John Buck walk if it meant I would re-sign Downs because he’s that good.
Jason Frasor: 33-year old righty reliever Jason Frasor pitched in 69 games (0 starts) for the Blue Jays this year and he was 3-4 with 4 saves, a 3.68 ERA and a 1.38 WHIP. VERDICT: I think some team will give him more than the Blue Jays will be willing to offer so I see him pitching for some other team in 2011.
Kevin Gregg: 32-year old righty closer Kevin Gregg made the 9th inning more exciting than it probably had to be but he usually got the job done. Gregg pitched in 63 games (0 starts) for the Blue Jays last year and he was 2-6 with 37 saves, a 3.51 ERA and a 1.39 WHIP. The club has a option for 2011 valued at $4.5 million bucks. VERDICT: If I were running the Blue Jays I would pick up Gregg’s option as $4.5 million bucks is a fair price for a closer like him.